Browse our carriers As an independent agency, SafeInsure has established long-term, solid relationships with the top national and regional carriers. We provide comprehensive, expert insurance solutions and service. Metlife Phone: 800-638-5433 Website: Visit Website Claims: Make a claim Progressive Phone: 855-758-0630 Website: Visit Website Claims: Make a claim Travelers Phone: 800-842-5075 Website: Visit Website Claims: Make a claim ASI Phone: 866-274-8765 Website: Visit Website Claims: Make a claim Foremost Insurance Group Phone: 800-527-3907 Website: Visit Website Claims: Make a claim Allstate Contact: Phone & chatWebsite: Visit Website